Now we come to it. The pressure is on. The task? To prove beyond a reasonable doubt that “Unemployable”, b-side to “World Wide Suicide” and centerpiece album track on Pearl Jam’s 8th album, is worthy of inclusion in the pantheon of classic tracks that includes “Corduroy”, “Rearviewmirror”, “I Got Shit”, and “Jeremy”, among many others. Odd choice? Some believe it is, and of course there’s no accounting for taste. But without (hopefully) sucking all of the greatness out it, I seek to demonstrate that “Unemployable” combines everything Pearl Jam does well into one mighty little three-minute package.

When the “World Wide Suicide” single hit airwaves and mp3 single format, I was pleasantly surprised to hear that song’s energetic hook and more mature political writing. But I was even more taken aback by “Unemployable”, more so than probably any track since “Who You Are”. Message board pundits went straight for the throat in comparing Ed’s “whoa-uh-oh’s” in the song’s chorus to (gasp) Shania Twain of all people. Shania Twain? First of all, though I have been in enough strip malls to know the song people are referring to, seriously people, if that’s the first song that comes to your mind, that’s your fault, not Ed’s. Noting Pearl Jam’s “Brass In Pocket” improv from the early days, “Unemployable” should at least resonate as being inspired somewhat by the Pretenders’ “Back on the Chain Gang”. But for the sake of argument, even if Twain’s vocal mannerisms did somehow consciously or subconsciously inspire Ed’s performance, does it or does it not sound great? Answer: it does.

The combination of writing, subject matter, instrumental and vocal performances, originality of the musical composition, and catchiness all dovetail into a fairly indestructible rock and roll box. Each aspect of the song balances the next. Though the issues the song deals with are no less than serious, the singable hook and “ooohhhh’s” prevent the song from ever being mired in its own seriousness. Lyrically, Vedder’s imagery has rarely been as fresh or real. Witness:

“He’s got a big gold ring that says ‘Jesus Saves’
And it’s dented from the punch thrown at work that day
When he smashed a metal locker where he kept this things
After the big boss said ‘you best be on your way'”

Visually, aurally, and texturally these lines can’t help but be experienced. You can imagine the dented locker, the sound of the fist hitting, the feel of bruised knuckles, the flash of a gold ring, the coldness of the boss’s voice: all of it. And that’s the point of the song: whether or not this exact experience has happened to you in every detail, you are forced to see it, hear it, feel it, and best of all, make your own mind up about it. It’s no secret that Pearl Jam’s history of populism and leftist politics makes it all but certain where their sympathies lie in “Unemployable”, i.e. not with the big boss but with the now-unemployed working man. But the song stops short at railing against the suits, asking instead, with little polemics, for listeners to consider the real-life implications of poor job security and an uncertain economy.

“Well, his wife and kids are sleeping but he’s still awake
On his brain weighs the curse of 30 bills unpaid
Gets up, lights a cigarette he’s grown to hate
Thinking if he can’t sleep, how will he ever dream?”

There are two particularly masterful lines in this verse, primarily because what they’re doing is so hard for most other writers to pull off. First, cigarettes are usually WAY overused in movies, poetry, and music to try and simulate some sort of jaded cool, to create a mood, etc. Here, the cigarette is just a cigarette, a detail that feels both realistic for the character, and appropriate for that moment when he can’t sleep. Plus, we’re told he’s grown to hate it. Why? Maybe because cigarettes cost $6 a pack, and without a job, that money’s probably better spent on feeding his family. Or because he’s so stressed out, the nicotine no longer calms his nerves or gives him satisfaction, despite an addiction. Well played Ed, well played.

The second bit of brilliance is that last line, “Thinking if he can’t sleep / How will he ever dream”. This is a fantastic example of one’s metaphor working in total conjunction with the actual circumstances of the story. The line works both literally and figuratively. Too many writers rely solely on the latter, which ends up sounding trite or baseless. But here, the sleeping and dreaming are both literally longed for, and the dreaming means both actual dreams and the character’s waking dreams for his family’s future. What this line pulls off wholly without pretension is something that poses a surprisingly large challenge for artists in all media.

And of course, none of this would mean anything at all if the song weren’t solidly and pleasingly constructed. Happily, “Unemployable” sounds fresh, earthy, tough, pretty, endless adjectives. The first thing I notice is Matt Cameron’s stick and cymbal work in the opening moments. How many songs do you know where the cymbals stand out enough to exclaim, “damn! those cymbals sound great”? Cameron’s inventive rhythms and playing inform “Unemployable” in ways that are creative but unobtrusive. The song flows as easily as any of the band’s poppier efforts, but with enough quirkiness to push themselves and listeners. The verse riffing underneath Vedder’s sublimely double-tracked vocals makes your insides move, as the song itself feels full of motion, stoic but worried, proud but frustrated, fluid yet turbulent, coming to the sad realization that for too many people this life is indeed “sacrifice”, when a disproportionate amount of the fruit of their labors is sent to those who have never known an honest day’s work.


~ by Michael on September 24, 2007.

6 Responses to “Unemployable”

  1. You nailed it. This is the song I immediately gravitated toward on Avocado. And that’s saying something, considering the wealth of great tracks present.

    Yes, WWS and Severed Hand, both unveiled (to me at least) on SNL, were strong. But this song, Unemployable, had it all: evocative lyrics, inventive guitar and vocal melodies, and harmonies. Honest-to-goodness vocal harmonies.

    I can’t describe what a treat this simple addition was for me. Vocal harmonizing is all but nonexistent in PJ’s catalog — and if it’s there, it’s overpowered by Eddie’s lead track. But on Avocado we get not only Unemployable, but also WWS and Army Reserve, all with very audible harmonizing by Matt.

    In fact, Matt says in Picture in a Frame, “I forgot how much I sing on the new songs.”

    In addition to the wonderful lyrics already posted, I’m struck every time by the sorrow of the second chorus:

    So this life is sacrifice / To a stranger’s bottom line

    What a great song. What a great album.

  2. This song sucks man. Ha, just kidding, it is my favorite from Avocado, bar none. Nice review.

  3. I agree, you hit it right on the head. I never understood the Shania Twain thing either – as if she were the first person to ever use “Whoa-oh-oh” in a song.

    There is a real claustrophobia to the lyrics, that helpless feeling of your entire life hanging at the mercy of someone else’s finger snapping. It’s devastatingly effective.

    And I couldn’t agree more about the vocal harmony. That’s one of the big things that sets the new album apart from all their others. Stone and Jeff both have fairly puny voices, but Matt’s is full-bodied enough to really create a layer with Ed’s lead lines. “Severed Hand” is another one, in addition to those mentioned, which really benefits from Matt’s contributions. Even on the 2006 tour, he really stepped up and contributed backup to some songs that didn’t used to have it otherwise (listen to Stone’s comment re “Evenflow” on 5/12/06 – clearly the band thinks the same way we do).

  4. This was a great write-up, C-13. I know you’ve been ready to unleash this one for awhile, and I think you succeeded in presenting your points effectively.

    I like how this song showcases, concisely, what Matt Cameron has brought to the band. I too enjoy enjoy the vocal harmonies and I think that the lyrics are incredibly strong.

    I’m not quite ready to hail this song as one of the band’s best, however. There’s no reason for that other than the fact that it just hasn’t grabbed ahold of me yet. I’m sure that in time it will. As for now, it is still one of the best songs (if not the best) on the new album in my opinion. I’ll come back to it over the years to see if my affection for it gets any stronger.

  5. I’ve listened with intent and purpose…I’ve read with open mind and heart…and I still think “Army Reserve” is a better song than “Unemployable”…and I like “Severed Hand” even more…depending on my mood. There is no question the lyrics of “Unemployable” are deep and interesting…but the entire album was a strong step forward for lyrics…(and harmonies). And, it’s only two verses. And the end gets repetitive. Just when I’d like a guitar solo, I get more “yeah…this life is sacrifice”…on and on until the end. I must admit, I haven´t heard a live version…or…if i have, i don’t remember it…i think it’s in concert where songs do or don’t, make or break, live or die…so, these stellar comments are well received, but i’m afraid I’m still unconvinced…I’ll listen to a few live versions, wait a few years to see where the song goes…and save my crow eating for later…but for now…”unemployable” is still my least favorite song on Pearl Jam.

  6. What a great write-up C13. I love this song, too. You didn’t convince me that it’s in the same league as RVM and CORDUROY, but it’s still a great song. I don’t have much to add to what others have said except that I went the full mile and listened to both BRASS IN POCKET and the Shania Twain song along with UNEMPLOYABLE. I don’t know if you have an interest in commenting on this, but there is a whole lot more going on musically in UNEMPLOYABLE than in either BRASS IN POCKET or Ms. Twain’s song. It all combines to give the song such a feeling of movement. I wouldn’t have noticed if you hadn’t brought up those other songs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: