Falling Down/Fallen

There’s a lot of mystery/contradictory information out there regarding the song that has come to be known as “Falling Down”. An old issue of Rumor Pit claims that the music was written by Ed Vedder. However, part of the song was later recycled to become “Distress”, by Mike McCready side project The Rockfords, which is credited to the guitarist and his bandmates. Furthermore, in the packaging of Lost Dogs, the song title “Fallen” is clearly visible on one of the many master tapes in the central photograph, leading some to speculate that “Falling Down” and “Fallen” are one and the same.

The only live performance of “Falling Down” occurred on June 20, 1995, at Red Rocks Amphitheater in Colorado, during the sit-down, acoustic set that opened the show. It doesn’t appear on the written setlist, as it should between “Footsteps” and “Betterman”. But arrowed between those two songs, with a tentative question mark, is “This Boy”. Now, “This Boy” is a song by That Dog that the band tagged onto “Daughter” at the very same show, and would be covered by Ed on its own later that year. But the lyrics to “Falling Down” do include “You’re a boy / You’re a boy / You’re a boy”, so is this a connection or red herring?

Most Pearl Jam songs that are only played once, never to be heard from again, and which are titled by bootleggers, turn out to be improvisations: from “Seven Years Waiting” to “On the Moon”. But “Falling Down” sounds just put together enough to qualify as a fully-conceived composition.  It’s not completely developed, particularly with regards to the lyric and vocal melody, but it’s not far off.   The opening  “Distress” guitar riff is ambling and pastoral with the same sort of wistful charm as “Untitled”, and the lyrics are also nostalgic: “Oh something to remember me by / Oh something to place in your hand.” Then the song shifts abruptly to a darker, minor-chord chorus for the hook, “I’m falling down.”

Ed’s performance is hesitant, as if the decision to play the song was spontaneous and gung-ho, but actually singing it revealed what was unfinished for him.  The long instrumental section/McCready’s solo is as epic as you’d expect, and would be very interesting to hear from a studio version.  The song also goes through an extended outro with Ed repeating “I cannot apologize”, which blurs the line a little bit between improv and finished work.  Perhaps “Falling Down” is really half-and-half, an experiment blending a completed instrumental with Ed given free reign to test out some of his notebook ideas. Whatever it is, the song has sparked the imagination of fans the way all unreleased Pearl Jam songs have, and the hopes it will one day be explained.

Advertisements

~ by Michael on June 5, 2007.

4 Responses to “Falling Down/Fallen”

  1. Happy to say I was at both those Red Rock shows in 95…and that short altitude induced “acoustic” set to open the second night will be forever cemented in my memory. (Especially the new version of Jeremy…maybe my all time favorite…not so much for the music, which might be enough, but more because of the memory of the moment of realization). So for me, all the songs in that set are like one. The whole set seemed to be something that they decided to do at the last minute, and maybe more importantly, something they didn’t do very often around that time…sit close to each other and play intimate songs. The whole thing was improvised, or at least unrehearsed. At one point, Ed says, “uh, we’re obviously just making this up as we go along.” And the cover of “Ship Song” falls apart. “uh, we need to work that one out…sounded great backstage.” So, “Falling Down”sounds “hesitant…spontaneous and gung-ho” because the whole set was like that. Hearing the bootleg later, much later, I just love the lyrics…”something to remember me by”…so true…

  2. I love this song. Saw it live. Forgot about it. Heard the bootleg. Loved it. Wrote a better comment earlier, but didn’t go through. So, trying again to see if I can do this right.

  3. Awesome write-up Oleyver. I’m completely jealous that you were at the Red Rocks show. Sounds like it was amazing. I might have to give the reworked “Jeremy”, “Wash”, “Corduroy”, and “Porch” (though I don’t have a copy of that one yet), their own entries.

  4. I haven’t heard this one…I will look for it and then I will drop some lines about it

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: