Garden

I was all set to go on “Go”, until the intro to the Grateful Dead’s “New Potato Caboose” from Live From the Vault inexplicably came out of the speakers and sounded eerily close to “Garden”. That’s just the first of several strange thoughts now caroming around my skull while I look for a suitable angle on what I’ve always found to be quite a mysterious song.

If any song on Ten could be classified as unsung (kind of a stretch), it might have to be “Garden”. It’s one of the few songs from their debut album not to have appeared on any of the demo tapes, which suggests it was written close to or during the London Bridge recording sessions. And though it was played with frequency during their first few tours, it disappeared from 1995-2000, and has received only occasional (and in 2006, re-worked) treatment since.

If “Garden” was written in the studio, it might have been specifically worked on to add a different dimension to Ten that was otherwise missing. Had the album included “Alone”, “Brother”, “Girl”, or even “Breath” in its place, Ten would have been one fist-pumping rock anthem too many. “Garden” is spooky and atmospheric in ways to which no other Ten-era track can lay claim. It’s no less heavy however, particularly at its climax, an aspect the band amplified in support of Pearl Jam.

“Garden” also contains, in seed form, a lot of the themes Vedder would explore in more and greater depth on future albums. “I don’t question our existence / I just question our modern needs”, he sings vaguely, though he’d elaborate on “Do the Evolution”, “Present Tense”, and “Education”. Still, “Garden” is beautifully moody, and lends its album a haunting, pensive quality to balance its more straight-forward aggression.

Advertisements

~ by Michael on May 26, 2007.

8 Responses to “Garden”

  1. “Had the album included “Alone”, “Brother”, “Girl”, or even “Breath” in its place, Ten would have been one fist-pumping rock anthem too many.” – C13

    I couldn’t agree more.

  2. As C13 says this song is beautifully moody and haunting song. The reworked version for the 2006 tour sounds good also, especially in the chorus where the crowd sings in the “old” way

  3. C13 – “it disappeared from 1995-2000”

    It was played in 2000, also a reworked version, and different than the 2006 reworked arrangement.

  4. From 1995 until 2000; got it on the Tampa boot!

  5. You never really gave your personal opinion on this song. What do you think of it?

  6. C13: “From 1995 until 2000; got it on the Tampa boot!”

    Yeh sorry, I misunderstood that.

  7. “You never really gave your personal opinion on this song. What do you think of it?”

    If pressed, ;), I’d have to say that I think the song works really well as a mood piece, and within the context of the album. I loved hearing the reworked version… musically it’s pretty strong, but as a whole, not one of their strongest.

  8. i think this is an incredible song, but honestly i dont listen to it all that much by itself. like you said its good just for the atmosphere, so i really only hear it when im listening to the rest of the album, but when i do its so mindblowingly good. its just not heavy and fun like the others, its just straight up emotion, so its not as easy to single it out to listen to by itself. definitely one of their best songs though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: