In 2002, George W. Bush was only in the second year of his first term as president of the U.S., but by that point he had already become one of the most divisive and polarizing figures in American history. The epitome of evil to some, a symbol of power and pride to many others–the mention of his name in any context could elicit hissing or chants of “USA! USA!” During the 2003 Riot Act tour, Pearl Jam received plenty of boos and cheers whenever they pulled out “Bu$hleaguer”. Where most of Pearl Jam’s political songs addressed ideals and events, this song was about a particular figure at a particular moment in history. Accordingly, no other Pearl Jam song shook up the band’s fanbase quite the same way.

As I’ve written before regarding political songs, they’re extremely tough for even the best artists to pull off. The biggest problem is that it’s easy for a writer to create their own strawmen, or become them. Devoting an entire song to Bush unfortunately makes it too easy for people to dismiss the song simply as another “Bush-hating” liberal attack job. Though there are real issues alluded to in the song, from nepotism to energy policy, but as the name of the song is “Bu$hleaguer”, otherwise interested listeners are already primed to tune out. Even in 2007, when many Republicans are starting to realize that the Bush presidency has been somewhere between a failure and absolute catastrophe, the song is a little tough to swallow–as if the target was too easy.

Contrast the line “born on third, thinks he got a triple”, with “a handsome face / that the president took for granted / writing checks that others pay.” While it’s clear to anyone listening to “World Wide Suicide” who that president is, the description of their attitude toward other people’s sacrifices is probably true for most presidents throughout history, just as most (but not all) U.S. presidents have come from privileged backgrounds. The baseball joke from “Bu$hleaguer”, while I might appreciate it, is a petty jab. Sure, it’s the tone of song to be wry and sarcastic, but it just isn’t as powerful as it could be.

Musically, however, the song is very interesting.  Somewhere out there, a recording exists of Vedder singing the verses, but he ultimately speaks them in an almost improbably low grumble.  For all of my queasiness about “I’m Open” and “I’m Still Here”, “Bu$hleaguer” is probably my favorite Vedder spoken word performance.  Even though the humor doesn’t always win me over, the fact that the overall tone is humorous makes Vedder’s voice easier to listen to, as it rolls and tumbles over all kinds of interesting wordplay. Gossard’s music is  at times dark, metallic, bruising–very dramatic, at other times casual and jangly.  The lines “Blackout weaves its way through the city”, which I believe pre-date Vedder’s lyrics, feature some creepy-ass doubled vocals.  This is my favorite part of the song, as well as the chorus–which suggests all sorts of shit the Bush administration has stirred up, from the botched, corporate-led “rebuilding” of Iraq, to the behind-closed-doors scripting of the nation’s energy policy, all without one-liners that make it too easy for someone to confuse putting a mask on mic-stand with “impaling” it.


~ by Michael on May 21, 2007.

14 Responses to “Bu$hleaguer”

  1. A very good analysis of a controversial song. When I’m listening to the song and not paying attention to the words, I find it hypnotic. The chorus is really wonderful. I believe the spoken words are meant to be humorous, but I’m not sure that I even understand all of them. That said, the main criticisms of this song that I’ve seen, that it is silly or sophomoric, simply don’t stand up.

  2. I think we’re totally on the same page with this one Susan. I don’t find the song silly or sophomoric, but all that extremely coded language is just impenetrable. I chalk it up to failed experiment–at least as far as the verses are concerned. Or a noble attempt. That sounds better.

  3. Failed experimnt is an adequate label for this song. I LOVE the chorus….I really think it’s a great moment on Riot Act. But the verses have always given me trouble. I’m not as much anti-spoken word as I am anti-spoken-words-that-don’t-make-much-sense. Is it a terrible song? No. It’s on par with the rest of the album….mediocre, borderline lazy tune. To me, it’s a throwaway track with a brilliant, haunting chorus.

  4. We all agree on the chorus (so far)! We rock.

  5. Another excellent write-up. I have to agree that the highlight of this song is the ‘blackout weaves its way’. Someone earlier described it perfectly – Hypnotic.

  6. I just watched a DVD of the Arnhem 06 show, one of the most intense versions of the song i have seen. When Ed takes off the mask to begin singing, he pauses to look at Bu$h, and seemingly disgusted with the President’s very existence, spits on the mask.
    Another notable live version is the version from San Fran, also this year, in which Ed prefaces the song with an acapella ‘Georgie Boy’ tag. Worth checking out.

  7. I don’t like so much that song. But it has too much to say and that’s the point.

  8. Ive actually gotten to love this song. I agree with everyone that the chorus is great. But I also like the first verse and the parts of the second verse that i understand.

  9. @BugWaveRider: I was at that show in Arnhem, my first PJ concert! I downloaded the show from the Pearl Jam site as soon as it was available and listen to it regularly. But now I MUST have that DVD you mention! Is it available from the Ten Club? Can;t seem to find it online.

  10. Stone’s guitar playing on “Bu$hleager”: phenomenal

    The Bush presidency: not so phenomenal

    C13’s review of Bu$hleaguer: priceless

  11. Why thank you BYM!

  12. Send me an e-mail Alberto, i’ll hook you up. The DVD is fanshot, but pointed at one of the big screens, so it is basically a pro-shot.

  13. The “born on third base and thinks he hit a triple” is actually a line from the late great columnist Molly Ivins.

    Having said that, great write up, great blog.

  14. […] Ghost 6. I Am Mine 7. Thumbing My Way 8. You Are 9. Get Right 10. Green Disease 11. Help Help 12. Bu$hleaguer 13. 1/2 Full 14. Arc 15. All Or […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: